Brick home entry with a charcoal door, white-framed window and black shutters, concrete steps, a clay-paver walk and an autumn oakleaf hydrangea.

Downtown Noblesville Square: New Shops to Watch in Fall 2026

October 15, 2026

The new owners of 894 Logan St. took over a floor of mismatched flooring left from the years when a carpet company used the space. When they pulled up the carpet, they found the building's original hardwood floors from 1868, and they decided to keep as much of them as they could. They told Current in Noblesville that they would.

That storefront faces the Hamilton County Courthouse along Logan Street, which has been fenced, dug up and partly closed since April. Three months earlier, a business at that address announced it was closing because of the construction. Its replacement planned an October opening while crews were still laying brick out front.

Same Address, Eleven Weeks Apart

The Velvet Plum Vintage & Consignment, a home decor and furniture consignment shop, had been at 894 Logan St. for six years. In late June, Current in Noblesville reported that the shop would close July 15 and that the owners named Embrace Downtown construction as the main reason. Work on Logan Street had started in April.

The same story reported that the owners' other antique and vintage store, at 939 Conner St., would stay open. The Logan Street operations moved to Consigned By Design in Indianapolis.

The next tenant is local. Becca Wormuth, Jacqueline Beeler and Cassandra Brown own County Line Collective at Hamilton Town Center. They set Oct. 2 as the opening date for a second store, The Collective on the Square, at 894 Logan St., according to Current in Noblesville. The shop combines three of their businesses. Brown makes graphic apparel for adults and children under County Line Apparel. Wormuth and her husband make handmade wooden signs and decor as Stain Haven. Beeler's Without Borders Boutique & Permanent Jewelry carries boutique clothing and permanent jewelry. They also plan to use the basement for open houses, ladies' nights and other events. The Hamilton Town Center store stays open.

The two dates are 79 days apart. During those weeks, the construction fencing was still up.

Logan Street Kept Filling While It Was Fenced

894 Logan St. isn't the only address on this block to change this year. Here is the order of events on the Logan Street side of the square in 2026:

Date What happened Address
April 15 Phase 1B construction begins; Logan Street closed east of Eighth through Ninth Logan St., Eighth to Ninth
July 15 The Velvet Plum's announced closing date 894 Logan St.
By mid-August The Pretender Hi-Fi Lounge & Bar reported open 818 Logan St.
Sept. 8 Underground work for Phase 1B complete; clay brick pavers going in Logan St.
Oct. 2 The Collective on the Square's scheduled opening 894 Logan St.

The Pretender is the bigger bet of the two. It opened in the middle of Phase 1B on the same block. Current in Noblesville describes it as a listening bar built around turntables, Tannoy and Sansui speakers and a vintage reel-to-reel player. It serves small plates and a cocktail menu. Uncanned Music made analog tapes specifically for the room, local DJs spin vinyl on weekends, and guests can bring their own records.

So a shop closed over the construction, and two new businesses committed to the same block before the work ended. Neither one waited for the finished streetscape.

Where the Construction Actually Stands

The schedule explains why that timing matters. The city's Phase 1B announcement laid out how the work would run. Logan Street would be closed from east of Eighth Street through the Ninth Street intersection, while the Eighth and Logan intersection stayed open. A six-foot sidewalk along the building fronts would keep shop entrances reachable. The rest of the sidewalk and street, out to the courthouse seat wall, would close in stages as work moved along. Parking on Logan between Eighth and Ninth would be unavailable.

Phase 1C comes after Phase 1B ends. In that phase, the temporary six-foot frontage sidewalk is removed and replaced with a decorative paver sidewalk. The city targets November 2026 for completing the overall project, weather permitting.

The latest progress report on the project site is the September 2026 newsletter, dated Sept. 8. It says the underground work for Phase 1B is complete, crews have started installing clay brick pavers, and Phase 1B is expected to wrap up this fall, depending on weather. No later update on the project site confirms that Logan Street has fully reopened or that Phase 1C has started. If you're heading downtown this month, plan on the frontage-sidewalk setup still being in place.

The same newsletter reports results from the Embrace Small Business stamp program, which the city ran to keep customers coming downtown during construction. It logged 2,165 individual transactions, and the city estimates more than $200,000 in economic impact for downtown Noblesville. The project team is also featuring individual downtown businesses on its Facebook and Instagram accounts, with $50 gift cards to four winners.

The Next Two Addresses Are a Block or More Off Logan

The square isn't the only part of downtown with new projects on the way. King Jugg Brewing Company is building a downtown location at 151 N. Eighth St., which IndyStar reported in July was under construction. That report did not include an opening date. An earlier Current in Noblesville story from January 2025 projected completion in 2027, so a 2026 pint at that address looks unlikely.

A longer-range project is under way on Pleasant Street. On Sept. 2, city officials broke ground on The Granary, a $64 million mixed-use development with 223 apartments and commercial space, according to Current in Noblesville. It is the first private development along the Pleasant Street corridor, and it is expected to be finished by the end of 2028.

Taken together, the timeline runs from Logan Street in 2026 to Eighth Street to Pleasant Street in 2028. The square is the first piece to finish.

The Dates the New Tenants Are Counting On

The Collective's owners gave a specific reason for moving onto the square. "Being at the mall is amazing, but being from Noblesville, getting to be on the square means getting to participate in events like Small Business Saturday and the Indiana Peony Festival," Beeler told Current in Noblesville. The first of those events is a few weeks away, and the city's November target for finishing construction falls just before it.

Here are the dated events from now through December, in order:

  1. Halloween at Forest Park, Friday, Oct. 23, 4:30 to 7:30 p.m. This free city event at 701 Cicero Road includes a trick-or-treat trail, costume contest, hayrides, games, a DJ and food vendors. Some activities require wristbands, and you need to register in advance for those, according to the City of Noblesville calendar.
  2. Small Business Saturday, Nov. 28. This will be the first one for The Collective on the Square, listed on the Noblesville Main Street 2026 calendar.
  3. Deck the Downtown Weekend, Dec. 5 and 6. This is Main Street's main holiday weekend, and it lands about a week after the end of the city's November construction target.
  4. Main Street Holiday Gala, Dec. 10, and Holiday Market, Dec. 12. Both are listed under "Soon to be Announced" on the Main Street calendar, so the details may still change.

The 2026 Main Street calendar doesn't include the Lighting of the Square. The city's holiday announcement that lists it on Nov. 29 was posted in November 2025 and covers last year's events, so that date isn't confirmed for 2026. Check the Embrace Downtown project site and the Main Street calendar before planning a December evening around it, since the sidewalk layout on Logan may look different by then.

The Farmers Market Days season at Federal Hill Commons ended Oct. 10. The next Saturday on the Main Street calendar is Small Business Saturday on Nov. 28.

If you own a home near downtown Noblesville and want to know how the new streetscape, new storefronts and the projects coming to Eighth and Pleasant streets figure into its value, Sue Pfohl has followed this market for more than three decades and can walk you through what has changed. Request a free home valuation to see where your home stands this fall.

Work With Sue

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact Sue today.